Two Guys, a Girl and a TV Set

Three college friends out in the world, filling the void with television…and loving it.

ER Without the Room (Trauma Premiere Review)

Posted by Mr. Feeny on September 29, 2009

“You run so fast, all of you, you miss the point entirely.” – Dr. Saviano
“There’s a point?” – Nancy

That’s what I was wondering with every explosion and crash. What’s the point? Where is this going? (Isn’t it nice when writer’s include such a perfect line? It’s like they almost realized I’d need it.)

There’s a ton of action in Trauma. After all, this chronicles the day-to-day activities of the first responders. The ones who treat victims on the scene and transport them to doctors. An interesting world, but I wonder if it will get old after a while. Everything has to take place in a traumatic situation…no time to really digest or advance stories, so it would seem. And, won’t we just be seeing things we’ve already seen in other medical dramas?

Again, almost on cue, the writers proved me wrong, in easily one of the best openings to a new show yet. DON’T READ this paragraph if you don’t want to know what happens. Just skip to the next one……….After trying to get to know these characters for the first five minutes, what happens? Their medical helicopter collides with another chopper and crashes in flames. With two of those characters on board. They cut to the title screen, and I expected them to return to that scene. How the others would rescue their friends. Instead, it opens a year later, with the radio mentioning the 1-year anniversary of the fatal helicopter crash. Regardless of what the rest of the show brought, that was exciting and surprising. It had me hooked. Especially since they killed off one of the seemingly lead characters. A great decision, since it adds a layer of problems to the routine drama.

But the rest of the episode was routine. As a semi-regular viewer of ER, I’ve seen it before. The characters, the situations, the medicine. Why do we need a replacement for it? I thought Jay Leno was replacing it. My title’s a bit misleading. This is ER with a whole lot of Emergency, no Room, and very little focus on the characters. ER was a hit because viewers cared about the personal lives of Dr. Ross, Dr. Green, Nurse Hathaway, etc. We only got to really know three characters, and frankly, only one is relatively interesting.

Rueben (Cliff Curtis), or “Rabbit,” initially comes across as your typical macho pilot character.¬† Headstrong, rule-breaking, insulting. That makes him the most enjoyable character, but not much in the area of caring about him. That changed midway through the episode. Following his accident, Rabbit tries to put on a strong front. But he reveals both his vulnerability and compassion. He’s a layered character. And those are the best. But right now, everyone else is flat as a dead guy’s line.

I’m going to keep watching this show to see if it becomes “must-watch.” But it’s worth 40 minutes if you have nothing better to do and enjoy action-packed adventures that are better suited for movies.

Grade: C+

Advertisements

One Response to “ER Without the Room (Trauma Premiere Review)”

  1. CJ Cregg said

    Hmmm. I might watch this if there was nothing else on TV. But given the myriad choices the viewer always has, I’m not sure why you would pick this over pretty much any other show.

    It was too much for me. The helicopter crash, and then the car crash and the gas. Too predictable. It’s gross, graphic. This is not my genre. Perhaps if you love ER-type shows, you’d like it. But these aren’t my favorite types of shows, so maybe that’s what I didn’t like it.

    “Rabbit” just made me think of Top Gun. Feeling like he’s responsible and that he should be dead, blah blah blah…we’ve seen this before. It’s like a bad Top Gun with emergency responders. I didn’t think his character had many layers. And then when the young woman slaps him at the end and goes off on how he almost killer her. She’s all “Do you want me to be your rotor?” Um, barf. Bad writing, too much blood, and way too overstimulating (in a bad way).

    Grade: C-

    Surely you can find something better than this on at the same time.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: